Soulscrape
Install the skill
Theme
Appearance

Public dossier section · @ben

coverage

This is @ben's profile revision 1. The original date and editorial confidence below are attributed to its publisher, not independent verification.

Original credited author: Hraness

AI-drafted at Ben Guo's direct request and credited to Hraness; every claim links to its cataloged source.

Back to the full profile · Markdown version · Original document

Published text

Original source occurrences

  1. social-inspiring vs distracting · adamfard.com · undated (unknown) · original ID: src-ci-adamfard-ux · Other public citations of this URL

    social-inspiring vs distracting; privacy intimidation

  2. monthly visit series 23 · admin.aitools.xyz · 2026-06 (month) · original ID: src-ci-aitools-traffic · Other public citations of this URL

    monthly visit series 23.1m (jul 25) → 10.47m (jun 26)

  3. third studio · associated press · 2025-09-04 (day) · original ID: src-ci-ap-wb · Other public citations of this URL

    third studio; superman/bugs bunny; "illegal copies" training allegation

  4. protest origin, nanitchkov image, counts · arstechnica.com · 2022-12-14 (day) · original ID: src-ci-ars-artstation · Other public citations of this URL

    protest origin, nanitchkov image, counts

  5. v5 alpha · arstechnica.com · 2023-03-16 (day) · original ID: src-ci-ars-v5 · Other public citations of this URL

    v5 alpha; hands; version chronology (v3 aug 2022, v4 nov 2022)

  6. warner bros. sues · arstechnica.com · 2025-09 (month) · original ID: src-ci-ars-wb · Other public citations of this URL

    "defiant and undeterred"; protections removed; $150k/work

  7. 43-page response · news.artnet.com · 2025-08 (month) · original ID: src-ci-artnet-fairuse · Other public citations of this URL

    43-page response; "cannot have it both ways"

  8. the 16,000-name style list · artnews.com · 2024-01-02 (day) · original ID: src-ci-artnews-list · Other public citations of this URL

    16k-name sheet; 6-yr-old hyan tran; jon lam screenshots

  9. warzels apology, prompt text verbatim · theatlantic.com · 2022-08 (month) · original ID: src-ci-atlantic-warzel-mistake · Other public citations of this URL

    warzel's apology, prompt text verbatim

  10. $300m 2024 claim · bbc.com · 2025-06-12 (day) · original ID: src-ci-bbc-disney · Other public citations of this URL

    $300m 2024 claim; character list; lawyer skepticism

  11. slop layer framing · bloodinthemachine.com · 2025 (year) · original ID: src-ci-bloodinthemachine-slop · Other public citations of this URL

    "slop layer" framing; 2023 chatgpt+midjourney ignition claim

  12. exhibit examples (superman texting · bloomberg · 2025-09-04 (day) · original ID: src-ci-bloomberg-wb · Other public citations of this URL

    exhibit examples (superman texting; batman+r2-d2)

  13. definitional analysis · igp.sipa.columbia.edu · 2026-06 (month) · original ID: src-ci-columbia-slop-report · Other public citations of this URL

    definitional analysis; john oliver 2025 slop episode note

  14. 1m-member cap breach · discord · undated (unknown) · original ID: src-ci-discord-case-study · Other public citations of this URL

    1m-member cap breach; 7m servers installed app; mega-server engineering

  15. how a computer designed this week's cover · economist.com · 2022-06-11 (day) · original ID: src-ci-economist-cover · Other public citations of this URL

    midjourney cover; ~250 prompts/~1000 images (archive.today mirror 0vrtz)

  16. onboarding/image-management complaints · embraceai.training · undated (unknown) · original ID: src-ci-embraceai-ux · Other public citations of this URL

    onboarding/image-management complaints

  17. cara third scrape · forbes · 2026-08-23 (day) · original ID: src-ci-forbes-cara-scrape · Other public citations of this URL

    cara third scrape; jingna zhang quote

  18. miyazaki-ethos irony framing · forbes · 2025-03-27 (day) · original ID: src-ci-forbes-ghibli · Other public citations of this URL

    miyazaki-ethos irony framing

  19. piracy framing · theguardian.com · 2025-06-11 (day) · original ID: src-ci-guardian-disney · Other public citations of this URL

    "piracy" framing; injunction sought

  20. how viral ai slop took over · theguardian.com · 2025-12-27 (day) · original ID: src-ci-guardian-slop · Other public citations of this URL

    slop genre history; woty

  21. horrible, horrible way to interact · hacker news · 2023-12 (month) · original ID: src-ci-hn-discord-ui · Other public citations of this URL

    "horrible, horrible way to interact"; install-base counter-argument

  22. discord as the genai foundation · blog.kowatek.com · 2024-05-29 (day) · original ID: src-ci-kowatek-discord · Other public citations of this URL

    20.3m largest community; genai-on-discord pattern

  23. entities suing · latimes.com · 2025-09-04 (day) · original ID: src-ci-latimes-wb · Other public citations of this URL

    entities suing; jury demand

  24. transformative-fair-use analysis · law.com · 2025-08-08 (day) · original ID: src-ci-lawcom-fairuse · Other public citations of this URL

    transformative-fair-use analysis; meta/anthropic rulings context

  25. limited monopoly…must give way to fair use verbatim · lightreading.com · 2025-08 (month) · original ID: src-ci-lightreading-mj-answer · Other public citations of this URL

    "limited monopoly…must give way to fair use" verbatim

  26. midjourney's answer · cdn.arstechnica.net · 2025-08-06 (day) · original ID: src-ci-mj-answer · Other public citations of this URL

    fair use; "tens of millions of users"; plaintiffs' employees subscribe; iger quote

  27. discords biggest failure argument · mofactor.com · 2026-03-08 (day) · original ID: src-ci-mofactor-discord · Other public citations of this URL

    "discord's biggest failure" argument; peak ~20.9m members sept 2024; dau 1.2–2.5m

  28. gpus are melting altman quote · nbcnews.com · 2025-03-26 (day) · original ID: src-ci-nbc-ghibli · Other public citations of this URL

    "gpus are melting" altman quote; 11k-creatives letter context

  29. wide-scale misinformation framing · nbcnews.com · 2023-03-27 (day) · original ID: src-ci-nbc-pope · Other public citations of this URL

    "wide-scale misinformation" framing; buzzfeed motive quote

  30. first-of-its-kind · npr.org · 2025-06-12 (day) · original ID: src-ci-npr-disney · Other public citations of this URL

    "first-of-its-kind"; 110pp; "virtual vending machine"; ~20m users

  31. last week tonight on ai images · youtube · 2022-08-28 (day) · original ID: src-ci-oliver-youtube · Other public citations of this URL

    10-min midjourney/ai-images segment; 5.0m views

  32. viral resurfacing of forbes quotes · petapixel.com · 2022-12-21 (day) · original ID: src-ci-petapixel-consent · Other public citations of this URL

    viral resurfacing of forbes quotes; metadata rebuttals

  33. class action filed · reuters · 2023-01-17 (day) · original ID: src-ci-reuters-andersen-filed · Other public citations of this URL

    class action filed; laion-5b; saveri/butterick

  34. disney and universal sue · reuters · 2025-06-11 (day) · original ID: src-ci-reuters-disney · Other public citations of this URL

    filing; "bottomless pit of plagiarism"

  35. core claims proceed · reuters · 2024-08-13 (day) · original ID: src-ci-reuters-orrick · Other public citations of this URL

    core claims proceed; discovery

  36. deepfates/willison coinage chain · scientificamerican.com · 2025 (year) · original ID: src-ci-sciam-slop · Other public citations of this URL

    deepfates/willison coinage chain; willison definition verbatim

  37. discord, the superapp for ai · signumgc.substack.com · 2024 (year) · original ID: src-ci-signum-discord · Other public citations of this URL

    19.8m members; 13m→19.8m yoy; discord monetization angles

  38. openai's ghibli moment · techcrunch · 2025-03-26 (day) · original ID: src-ci-techcrunch-ghibli · Other public citations of this URL

    flood timeline; style-not-copyrightable legal note

  39. lifted-protections allegation · techcrunch · 2025-09-05 (day) · original ID: src-ci-techcrunch-wb · Other public citations of this URL

    lifted-protections allegation; mj fair-use stance

  40. he doesn't need vc in his life · the information · 2023-09-05 (day) · original ID: src-ci-the-information-vc · Other public citations of this URL

    $200m pace; ~40 staff; profitable early; craigslist ambition; advisors (paywalled; quotes via secondary excerpts)

  41. théâtre d'opéra spatial registration refused · u.s. copyright office · 2023-09-05 (day) · original ID: src-ci-usco-theatre · Other public citations of this URL

    review board denial; ≥624 prompts; prompts-not-instructions holding

  42. trend escalation · the verge · 2025-03 (month) · original ID: src-ci-verge-ghibli · Other public citations of this URL

    trend escalation; darker remixes

  43. escalation framing · washingtonpost.com · 2025-06-11 (day) · original ID: src-ci-wapo-disney · Other public citations of this URL

    escalation framing

  44. loosened rules · washingtonpost.com · 2025-03-28 (day) · original ID: src-ci-wapo-ghibli · Other public citations of this URL

    loosened rules; historical-photo remixes

  45. he used ai to win a fine-arts competition · washingtonpost.com · 2022-09-02 (day) · original ID: src-ci-wapo-state-fair · Other public citations of this URL

    fair win; lamborghini-marathon analogy; judge quotes

  46. term history · wikipedia · undated (unknown) · original ID: src-ci-wikipedia-slop · Other public citations of this URL

    term history; 2022 origins; woty 2025 (merriam-webster + ads); willison role

  47. disney & universal v. midjourney — complaint · storage.courtlistener.com · 2025-06-11 (day) · original ID: src-hp-courtlistener-disney-complaint · Other public citations of this URL

    c.d. cal. no. 25-5275; delaware corp; hq sf

  48. an engine for the imagination · the verge · 2022-08-02 (day) · original ID: src-hp-verge-holz-2022 · Other public citations of this URL

    canonical holz interview; all verbatim quotes

Structured research records

  1. the studios arrive · midjourney-coverage-items · 2025-06-11 (day)

    Original location · source-d2bbaa568fdf72bb1028 · source-2f1d23c461b4722ae3b4 · source-c826efbfb8823a1f8fb2 · source-e995ed019dd23e43bea7 · source-18ba99c3976f50fb55bb · source-d4265f9420c59585b544

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": null,
      "date": "2025-06-11",
      "gist": "disney and universal file — the first major-studio ai suit: 'a bottomless pit of plagiarism,' a 'virtual vending machine' of unauthorized copies; holz's own scraping candor quoted back; $300m 2024 revenue and ~21m users alleged; injunction sought including against the imminent video launch.",
      "id": "cov-disney-suit",
      "publisher": "reuters / bbc / npr",
      "section": "lawsuits",
      "sentiment": "critical",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-reuters-disney",
        "src-ci-bbc-disney",
        "src-ci-npr-disney",
        "src-ci-guardian-disney",
        "src-ci-wapo-disney",
        "src-hp-courtlistener-disney-complaint"
      ],
      "title": "the studios arrive",
      "traction": "110 pages",
      "url": "https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/disney-universal-sue-image-creator-midjourney-copyright-infringement-2025-06-11/"
    }
  2. the answer · midjourney-coverage-items · 2025-08-06 (day)

    Original location · source-f1236de5750de82d8952 · source-c74f35c21dc8ba6673eb · source-a38f552c4ed7b985334f · source-7357bc605db56a91e32f

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": null,
      "date": "2025-08-06",
      "gist": "midjourney's answer — fair use: training extracts statistical information the way a person learns by looking; 'many dozens' of plaintiffs' own employees subscribe; bob iger's pro-ai quote is thrown back. combative.",
      "id": "cov-mj-answer",
      "publisher": "court filing / law.com / artnet",
      "section": "lawsuits",
      "sentiment": "mixed",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-mj-answer",
        "src-ci-lawcom-fairuse",
        "src-ci-artnet-fairuse",
        "src-ci-lightreading-mj-answer"
      ],
      "title": "the answer",
      "traction": "43 pages",
      "url": "https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/09/Disney-v-Midjourney-Answer-to-Complaint-8-6-25.pdf"
    }
  3. the third studio · midjourney-coverage-items · 2025-09-04 (day)

    Original location · source-371483567bcc3e2b071f · source-266acd027aee6f959c31 · source-f53f80fe3306d412e0c2 · source-27d120415254a6839bee · source-3daf0312bf29712918bf

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": null,
      "date": "2025-09-04",
      "gist": "warner bros. discovery becomes the third studio — superman, batman, bugs bunny, scooby-doo, rick and morty — alleging midjourney removed prior copyright protections after the disney suit and is 'defiant and undeterred.' up to $150k per work.",
      "id": "cov-wb-suit",
      "publisher": "ap / ars technica / bloomberg",
      "section": "lawsuits",
      "sentiment": "critical",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-ap-wb",
        "src-ci-ars-wb",
        "src-ci-bloomberg-wb",
        "src-ci-techcrunch-wb",
        "src-ci-latimes-wb"
      ],
      "title": "the third studio",
      "traction": null,
      "url": "https://apnews.com/article/warner-bros-midjourney-ai-copyright-lawsuit-dc-studios-b87d80d7b4a4dfdcf0ee149d30830551"
    }
  4. the ghibli moment · midjourney-coverage-items · 2025-03-26 (day)

    Original location · source-e8bcbea855cb88af3437 · source-156ba6a8df4b32bd908a · source-1beff96008c979ef4373 · source-2cc4a66ff5299eecd440 · source-2a5c6a6aad51d3d75b92

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": null,
      "date": "2025-03-26",
      "gist": "openai's ghibli moment — gpt-4o native images flood feeds with studio-ghibli selfies; 'our gpus are melting.' coverage frames it as the copyright-optics sequel to the midjourney artist-list story — and the viral center of gravity moving to chat platforms.",
      "id": "cov-ghibli",
      "publisher": "techcrunch / the verge / wapo",
      "section": "saturation",
      "sentiment": "mixed",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-techcrunch-ghibli",
        "src-ci-verge-ghibli",
        "src-ci-wapo-ghibli",
        "src-ci-forbes-ghibli",
        "src-ci-nbc-ghibli"
      ],
      "title": "the ghibli moment",
      "traction": "mainstream attention leaves the image labs",
      "url": "https://techcrunch.com/2025/03/26/openais-viral-studio-ghibli-moment-highlights-ai-copyright-concerns/"
    }
  5. the year of slop · midjourney-coverage-items · 2025-12-27 (day)

    Original location · source-567a95cac68193de6ba6 · source-0144ab25b68ba3688e98 · source-71807d0fa24323bfeba0 · source-ea04aa09b0f133c879d9 · source-ab134ed759a3b7d29034

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": null,
      "date": "2025-12-27",
      "gist": "the slop discourse peaks — 'slop' is merriam-webster's 2025 word of the year; the guardian's genre history runs shrimp jesus to erotic tractors. midjourney's output is both a canonical source of slop and, paradoxically, the benchmark it's judged against.",
      "id": "cov-slop",
      "publisher": "the guardian",
      "section": "saturation",
      "sentiment": "critical",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-guardian-slop",
        "src-ci-wikipedia-slop",
        "src-ci-sciam-slop",
        "src-ci-bloodinthemachine-slop",
        "src-ci-columbia-slop-report"
      ],
      "title": "the year of slop",
      "traction": "word of the year",
      "url": "https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2025/dec/27/from-shrimp-jesus-to-erotic-tractors-how-viral-ai-slop-took-over-the-internet"
    }
  6. the refuge, scraped · midjourney-coverage-items · 2026-08-23 (day)

    Original location · source-a58bc113d60f59fd3910

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": "rob salkowitz",
      "date": "2026-08-23",
      "gist": "cara — the anti-scrape artist refuge founded by andersen plaintiff jingna zhang — is scraped a third time in ten days. the consent fight is still live in mid-2026.",
      "id": "cov-cara-scrape",
      "publisher": "forbes",
      "section": "saturation",
      "sentiment": "critical",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-forbes-cara-scrape"
      ],
      "title": "the refuge, scraped",
      "traction": null,
      "url": "https://www.forbes.com/sites/robsalkowitz/2026/08/23/artists-built-a-site-to-escape-ai-scrapers-are-coming-for-it-anyway/"
    }
  7. the discord-dependency debate · midjourney-coverage-items · 2023–2026 (approximate)

    Original location · source-923bd7e106bc6eff5a31 · source-1a1a8fe1fed50a91610d · source-0d2829c86bd97ba8e852 · source-d4aaec2040e091b20f25 · source-51f3dc9569cb38814ed7 · source-0bc008cbc7279f3a6a46 · source-7c4c9a5b29a2a188f019

    Original structured fields
    {
      "author": null,
      "date": "2023–2026",
      "gist": "the discord-ux debate — 'discord is a horrible, horrible way to interact with it' (hn) vs. the counter-reading that the public-by-default server was free education and the install base. 2026 retrospectives call it both genius distribution and a cap on growth.",
      "id": "cov-discord-ux",
      "publisher": "hacker news / mofactor / ux audits",
      "section": "saturation",
      "sentiment": "mixed",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-hn-discord-ui",
        "src-ci-embraceai-ux",
        "src-ci-adamfard-ux",
        "src-ci-mofactor-discord",
        "src-ci-discord-case-study",
        "src-ci-signum-discord",
        "src-ci-kowatek-discord"
      ],
      "title": "the discord-dependency debate",
      "traction": null,
      "url": "https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38739054"
    }
  8. wonder · midjourney-sentiment-phases · 2022-03 → 2022-08 (approximate)

    Original location · source-e655d310436057af99b3 · source-dde9cfc864ea70e111cf · source-8091b9b666104c152e07

    Original structured fields
    {
      "evidence": "the discord co-creation spectacle, the economist cover, and john oliver's cabbage wedding — 'engine for the imagination' reads as utopian. coverage tone: delighted, low-stakes.",
      "id": "phs-wonder",
      "name": "wonder",
      "range": "2022-03 → 2022-08",
      "sentiment": "positive",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-economist-cover",
        "src-ci-oliver-youtube",
        "src-hp-verge-holz-2022"
      ]
    }
  9. backlash · midjourney-sentiment-phases · 2022-08 → 2023-01 (approximate)

    Original location · source-d85ef8abd54a446acf6c · source-f3347a4847923e3b1d28 · source-8e0040d0f48ed75ce7ad · source-d5fd5509083954a010ad · source-3fcc113e80ebb631a708

    Original structured fields
    {
      "evidence": "the state-fair win → the warzel pile-on → the artstation revolt → rutkowski → the consent quotes go viral → the class action filed january 2023. the theft/plagiarism frame consolidates.",
      "id": "phs-backlash",
      "name": "backlash",
      "range": "2022-08 → 2023-01",
      "sentiment": "critical",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-wapo-state-fair",
        "src-ci-atlantic-warzel-mistake",
        "src-ci-ars-artstation",
        "src-ci-petapixel-consent",
        "src-ci-reuters-andersen-filed"
      ]
    }
  10. normalization and realism panic · midjourney-sentiment-phases · 2023 (year)

    Original location · source-ad73f92c52f9b22547ac · source-d40e037bd9acd383c565 · source-a45ada7d2a0d12622ad0 · source-dfdb09e6477ac2e8136e

    Original structured fields
    {
      "evidence": "v5 photorealism → pope/trump → misinformation coverage, while professionals quietly adopt it and the business press discovers a profitable no-vc anomaly; the copyright office draws the doctrinal lines. tone: split — awe, resignation, fear.",
      "id": "phs-normalization",
      "name": "normalization and realism panic",
      "range": "2023",
      "sentiment": "mixed",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-ars-v5",
        "src-ci-nbc-pope",
        "src-ci-the-information-vc",
        "src-ci-usco-theatre"
      ]
    }
  11. the lawsuit era and the slop saturation · midjourney-sentiment-phases · 2024 → (approximate)

    Original location · source-e2ba6931edc370a6d136 · source-d0d43510aa07be1b8536 · source-d2bbaa568fdf72bb1028 · source-266acd027aee6f959c31 · source-0144ab25b68ba3688e98 · source-a8d9b654201096904c33

    Original structured fields
    {
      "evidence": "the style-list leak, orrick's discovery order, disney/universal, wb — plus 'slop' as word of the year and decaying traffic beside climbing revenue. legal accountability meets cultural fatigue; midjourney is no longer the face of ai images but remains the aesthetic reference point.",
      "id": "phs-lawsuit-slop",
      "name": "the lawsuit era and the slop saturation",
      "range": "2024 →",
      "sentiment": "critical",
      "sourceIds": [
        "src-ci-artnews-list",
        "src-ci-reuters-orrick",
        "src-ci-reuters-disney",
        "src-ci-ars-wb",
        "src-ci-wikipedia-slop",
        "src-ci-aitools-traffic"
      ]
    }